Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

FCAW Always Messy??

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • FCAW Always Messy??

    Used a FCAW wire feeder system at school the other night. Decent end result welds but the spatter is unbelievable; with or without shielding gas, 75/25. Just makes a mess. Instructor couldn't get it to do any better either; thought it was the wire grade/age.... Coupons were 1/2" armor plate.

    So today I put a roll of unshielded .035 on my Miller 211, removed the nozzle and immediately burned up the tip, worse spatter than in class. Tried several different WFS/V settings, none had any different results, all nasty messes. With the 211 even the end result welds weren't acceptable. Worse than any bad stick beads I've ever done. Coupons were 1/8" mild steel.

    According to our textbook FCAW now makes up about 50% of wire feed process usage. Someone is getting better results than we are for sure if that's true. :-)

    Open to any recommendations y'all may have.
    ==============
    Miller 211 MVP
    Hobart StickMate LX 235
    Lincoln AC 225
    CutMaster 42

  • #2
    FCAW Always Messy??

    I use fcaw wire(self shielding) in my passport and don't have any problems...a little spatter but that's expected....not sure what to tell you

    Comment


    • #3
      FCAW Always Messy??

      Did you switch the polarity on your 211?

      Comment


      • #4
        Add Content
        Attached Files

        Comment


        • #5
          Originally posted by kerr74 View Post
          Did you switch the polarity on your 211?
          That was it. We didn't do anything with polarity in class and I didn't think about it in my garage either. Even though it says on the chart to do that. Duh. :-)

          Pic 1 is DCEP and Pic 2 is DCEN. Will check the machine at school on Tuesday.

          Will also comment to Miller on their phone settings app. It doesn't say anything about polarity for flux core like it does for GMAW & SMAW. Also I notice that the settings app for flux core specifies 14-15 volts for .035 and 1/8" steel. Miller told me that the lowest setting on the 211 is 17 volts. I used the 5/35 setting from the chart for Pic 2.

          Thanks Kerr74.
          Attached Files
          ==============
          Miller 211 MVP
          Hobart StickMate LX 235
          Lincoln AC 225
          CutMaster 42

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by Thrutraffic View Post
            Used a FCAW wire feeder system at school

            According to our textbook FCAW now makes up about 50% of wire feed process usage. Someone is getting better results than we are for sure if that's true. :-)

            Open to any recommendations y'all may have.
            It is true but i think you have gasless flux core and gas flux core lumped together. It is two seperate wires and the cables are + -- for each wire usage. Gas flux core won't run without gas and gasless FCAW is just wasting gas if used.
            So post some more info on the wire. Our shop runs gas flux GMAW on every machine with perfect results...Bob
            Bob Wright

            Spool Gun conversion. How To Do It. Below.
            http://www.millerwelds.com/resources...php?albumid=48

            Comment


            • #7
              Flux Wire

              I work for a company that does structural steel and any in shop welding is done with .045 flux wire and shielding gas. The outcome and purpose for this process is completely worth it. Penetration and strength are that of field welding with 7018 rod. Self shielded flux core will always produce a small amount of spatter but not to the extreme. Self shield is good for small jobs with less than perfect steel and less than perfect welding conditions.

              Comment


              • #8
                Ok, the wire at school is an ESAB Dual Shield 710x. That's all I could get off the tag. The wire is black.

                I checked the power source, an Aircomatic 2.5 DTR-224-A, and it is wired DCEN. Machine may be older than I am. :-)

                The wire feeder is separate, on a boom arm.

                Again, it was running great beads but the spatter was the worst I've seen. Instructor and several other students welded with it, all with the same results.
                ==============
                Miller 211 MVP
                Hobart StickMate LX 235
                Lincoln AC 225
                CutMaster 42

                Comment


                • #9
                  http://www.esabx.com/index.cfm?active=active2&prod=710M
                  :~ATTITUDE MAKES THE DIFFERENCE!!!:

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Originally posted by Thrutraffic View Post
                    Ok, the wire at school is an ESAB Dual Shield 710x. That's all I could get off the tag. The wire is black.

                    and it is wired DCEN.
                    BINGO. That wire is supossed to be run DCEP +
                    I run the same wire 10 hours a day 6 days a week. Zero splatter with 75/25 and a little with CO2...Bob
                    Bob Wright

                    Spool Gun conversion. How To Do It. Below.
                    http://www.millerwelds.com/resources...php?albumid=48

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    X