Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Another Noob 240V Question or two --

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #31
    i have never seen one caused from a welder wiring and I have seen some shady setups. On a buzzer light wire can work but there is such a difference in drop between a 12 and a 10 it just works better and isn't a worry should someone haul azz and exceed the duty cycle. Something to consider is on a machine with a factory cord its likely a 12 (250a feeders come bigger) but 12 with a 50a plug. The main reason the breaker is there is as a disconnect and to provide for short circuit interruption. This is a circuit for a welder, the wire is protected by the theory that the machine will overheat before it cooks the wire,,, in the real world not so good, a buzzer will run fine wayyyyyyy beyond its rated output, that could cause a problem.

    Comment


    • #32
      For giggles look at the electric service guides for these macines. Miller doesnt reduce much confusion with theirs, they need a laymans guide with a mfg spec one step above code mins. Lincoln buzzers OM is worth looking at, they do not allow sub code installs, it sheds some light on some of this.

      Comment


      • #33
        Originally posted by BD1 View Post
        Congrats on your 211. Get a couple of fire extinguishers, a 5 gallon bucket with water, and have a garden hose connected if needed. You can also get those harbor freight welding blankets too. Starting a fire when it is not intended is not good. Wife may get upset. Those sparks have a way of find places to hide. Good luck.
        Thanks -- already on hand, and I'm not going to start burning anything until I have blankets. If I start a fire in the garage, her 1973 BMW R75/5 burns up -- and I won't survive the trauma!

        Originally posted by Sberry View Post
        For giggles look at the electric service guides for these macines. Miller doesnt reduce much confusion with theirs, they need a laymans guide with a mfg spec one step above code mins. Lincoln buzzers OM is worth looking at, they do not allow sub code installs, it sheds some light on some of this.
        After all the discussion about 12 gauge wire, I'm glad I went with 8!

        Comment


        • #34
          The main reason the breaker is there is as a disconnect and to provide for short circuit interruption.
          I understand that you are not going to give in on this point, but neither am I.

          The main reason for the breaker, any breaker/fuse, is to protect the wire, NOT the equipment. This is clearly stated in the NFPA NEC.

          There are other rules and recommendations regarding what size connector the equipment should have and what type of receptacle it should plug into. These are for the protection of the equipment. I understand that some welders come with "larger" plugs than their actual current draw and the NEC allows for larger breakers for a specific size wire to allow for the duty cycle of the welder, but these are not just "do it however you want" situations. There are very specific rules regarding wire size, breaker size, and welder duty cycles based on serious engineering calculations for the purpose of safety. Violation of these rules is not smart or clever, but is dangerous and, in most cases, illegal.

          If you look at the user manual for any welder, it will specify the wire size and breaker that is to be used. That information is NOT just a recommendation to be followed or not as the user thinks best. Using a smaller breaker, in the event that you do not plan to use the welder at it's max capacity is OK, as long as the breaker does not exceed that allowed for the wire size.

          After all the discussion about 12 gauge wire, I'm glad I went with 8!
          Me too!!

          Comment


          • #35
            Originally posted by Broccoli1 View Post
            Name:  f8120fa0d197334f52b35007862711e2.jpg
Views: 1
Size:  72.8 KB

            If I'm reading it correctly 12g wire can only be protected by a 40amp CB max.
            Depends on the wire type, and then you have to derate it (voltage drop, temp, multi-wire etc)

            Comment


            • #36
              If you look at the user manual for any welder, it will specify the wire size and breaker that is to be used. That information is NOT just a recommendation to be followed or not as the user thinks best. Using a smaller breaker, in the event that you do not plan to use the welder at it's max capacity is OK, as long as the breaker does not exceed that allowed for the wire size.
              no one is disagreeing with this, quite the contrary. What it says is this,,, a 14 is allowed for use with this machine (it comes with 12 cord) while it is suffecient to power the unit without overheating it within its rated output it is not legal to use a 14 on a breaker larger than 30. It is legal to use a 12 up to a 50 depending on applied load,,, in this case a welder that has its own thermal and will let the smoke out before overheating the incoming. The only or main reason this machine has a 12 cord is to allow it for use on common 50 welder circuits.

              It comes with factory 50 cord and plug,,, nema says its got to be able to be plugged to 50.

              Using a smaller breaker, in the event that you do not plan to use the welder at it's max capacity is OK, as long as the breaker does not exceed that allowed for the wire size.
              you cant derate a derate,, a greedy synch is an example. it has a minimum wire, you cant use less than that and overbreaker a 6 because the wireisunderto begin with,,, in this case the breaker is protecting wire,,, with the 211 it isnt,, the applied load is the limiting factor,,, similar to light fixtures,,, lots of 16 in the world connected to 20 breakers, load limited by the fact its connected to Edison base fixture. Control wiring same way, wire has to be heavy enough to fault a 20 breaker.

              There is nothing wrong with an 8,,, good for any unit that comes 50a including most 250 class feeders. I use it in most of my shop, you can run a buzzer way beyond its rated output. But unless this is really discussed beyond simple many never realize how its all rated and works.
              Last edited by Sberry; 05-02-2013, 07:29 PM.

              Comment

              Working...
              X